Are religious people likely to oppose genetic technologies?
As new and advanced reproductive genetic technologies (RGT) develop everyday, there are some groups of people who disapprove of such technologies.
A new study finds that people of faith are more likely to disapprove of such genetic tools than non-religious people.
This study which included general population survey of over 10000 people and 270 qualitative interviews, compared how people from different religious backgrounds evaluated disease RGT’s (detecting genetic disease in vitro) with enhancement RGT’s which allows parents to choose various features of a child.
Individuals participating in the survey were from the midwest and south of USA and included people from many religious backgrounds.
The study found that feelings on the use of RGT’s not only varied between religious and non- religious groups but also between various religious groups.
When the participants,were asked about the use of RGT’s for the prevention of disease, 23 per cent of the evangelicals said that this was morally wrong compared to nine per cent of Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and Jains, and eight per cent of Jews.
Religious participants, who supported enhancement RGT's, did so by considering that these technologies are provided within the concept of Co- creator Schema suggesting that there is a human partnership with God in improving our lives.
When asked about the use if RGT’s to select qualities such as hair color, eye color and gender, religious groups had a strong negative reaction with 80per cent of the evangelicals citing it to be morally wrong compared to 66 per cent Jews and 57 per cent Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and Jain.
55 per cent of agnostics and atheists said that this technology was morally wrong.
The study also found that the concept of Creator Schema – which emphasises God’s purpose and God’s plans in all human suffering predominated amongst the Evangical Christians, mainline Protestants and Muslims.
Jewish participants expressed ambivalence towards disease RGT’s and did not draw on Creator Schema.
Religious participants, who supported enhancement RGT’s, did so by considering that these technologies are provided within the concept of Co- creator Schema suggesting that there is a human partnership with God in improving our lives.
This study suggests that perhaps moral sensitivity must be taken into account when considering technologies which are complex and for which sufficient information is not available as would be the case for enhancements RGT’s.
Source: Sociological Forums
Join us as we walk 60km Path of Peace in Italy's Chiasco Valley
Following the footsteps of Italy’s patron saint St Francis, six people set off on a 60km walk through the undulating...
How to reconnect to your spirit to find more meaning in life
To be spiritually toxic is to be disconnected from your spirit. You don’t have to detox your spirit but you...
Would you walk the 800km Camino de Santiago?
From managing grief and finding your purpose to expanding your mind and connecting to your soul, life lessons come in...
How to reawaken your yoga practice with spirituality
Have you hit a yogic plateau and lost the spark in your practice? Here’s how to recharge your spiritual batteries...